With Christmas shopping putting more pressure on already stretched budgets, buying second-hand can be a great way to save money. Whether you’re hunting for toys on eBay, clothes on Vinted, vintage gifts on Depop or furniture on Facebook Marketplace, you could pick up something special for a fraction of the usual price.
But what happens if your Christmas bargain arrives damaged, looks nothing like the photos or doesn’t turn up in time? And can you return an unwanted gift after Christmas?
You might assume you have the same refund rights as shopping with a retailer. Unfortunately, that’s not always the case. Your rights depend on who you’re buying from, what’s gone wrong and which platform you’ve used. Here’s what you need to know before buying second hand gifts this Christmas.
What are your rights when buying second hand Christmas presents?
The biggest difference is whether you’re buying from a business or a private seller. When you buy from a business, you generally have protection under the Consumer Rights Act 2015. Your purchase must be as described, of satisfactory quality and fit for purpose, taking its age, condition and price into account. You may also have a 14 day cancellation right when buying online from a business, although exceptions apply.
Buying from a private seller is different. You don’t automatically have the right to return something because you’ve changed your mind, it doesn’t fit or the person you’ve bought it for doesn’t like it. However, the item must still match its description. If a seller advertises a designer handbag as genuine but sends you a fake, you may have grounds to challenge the sale.
Online marketplaces also have their own buyer protection schemes, which can offer additional ways to recover your money.
For more information, read Resolver’s guide to your retail and online shopping rights.
Can you get a refund on Vinted, eBay, Depop or Facebook Marketplace?
Each platform has different rules, particularly around how quickly you need to report a problem.
That’s especially important at Christmas, when you might buy presents weeks before giving them. Waiting until Christmas Day to check your purchases could mean missing the deadline to claim a refund.
Vinted
Vinted’s buyer protection generally covers eligible purchases made through its ‘Buy now’ system if your item doesn’t arrive, arrives damaged or is significantly different from its description.
For purchases from standard private sellers, you normally have just two calendar days from Vinted notifying you that the item should have arrived to report a problem. Don’t select ‘Everything is OK’ until you’ve checked your purchase. Different arrangements apply to Pro sellers, including additional statutory consumer rights.
If you’re having problems, read Resolver’s guide to common Vinted complaints.
eBay
Most eligible purchases made through eBay checkout are covered by its Money Back Guarantee. If your item doesn’t arrive, is damaged or doesn’t match the description, you can generally request a refund.
For most purchases, you have 30 calendar days from the estimated or actual delivery date to report a problem, depending on the type of claim. Contact the seller through eBay first. If they haven’t resolved the issue after three business days, you can ask eBay to step in.
Depop
Depop Protection covers eligible purchases made through its checkout system using Depop Payments. If your item doesn’t arrive, arrives damaged or is significantly different from its description, you can raise a claim.
You normally have 30 days from the purchase date to report the problem. Keep photographs and screenshots of the original listing, as Depop may ask for evidence before deciding whether to refund you.
Facebook Marketplace
Facebook Marketplace can be more complicated because many transactions take place directly between buyers and sellers. If you pay a seller directly or collect an item in person, you generally won’t have the same platform protection available through Vinted, eBay or Depop.
Some eligible purchases made through Facebook’s own checkout system may qualify for Purchase Protection, where that service is available. However, you shouldn’t assume every Marketplace transaction is covered. Be particularly careful when transferring money to someone you don’t know or paying before you’ve inspected an item.
Can you return an unwanted second hand Christmas present?
Not necessarily, if you’ve bought from a private seller and the item matches its description, you generally can’t demand a refund simply because the recipient doesn’t like it, it doesn’t fit or you’ve changed your mind. You can ask the seller whether they’ll accept a return, but they don’t usually have to agree.
When buying from a business seller online, you generally have a 14 day right to cancel eligible purchases without giving a reason, followed by another 14 days to return the goods. This applies to second-hand items too, although exceptions apply.
However, the cancellation period usually starts when you receive the goods, not when you give them as a present. That means buying a gift in November and waiting until Christmas to open it could leave you outside the cancellation window. Before buying, check whether the seller accepts returns and whether any extended Christmas returns policy applies.
What if your Christmas present arrives damaged or not as described?
If your purchase arrives broken, damaged or significantly different from the listing, report it through the platform as soon as possible. Take photographs showing the problem and save screenshots of the original description. Keep your messages with the seller and any packaging, particularly if the item was damaged during delivery.
Explain what’s wrong and what you’d like the seller to do. You may be entitled to a refund under the platform’s buyer protection scheme, even when buying from a private seller. However, each platform has its own eligibility rules and deadlines. Don’t wait until Christmas Day to discover whether that second-hand games console works or the designer jumper has an undisclosed hole. Check everything when it arrives, even if you plan to wrap it up straight away.
What if your second hand Christmas gift doesn’t arrive in time?
A late Christmas present is frustrating, particularly if you’ve ordered something specifically for the big day. If you’ve bought from a business and made it clear that delivery before Christmas was essential, you may have the right to cancel and request a refund if the agreed deadline is missed.
Buying from a private seller is different. Your rights depend on what was agreed, and you won’t automatically be entitled to a refund simply because an item arrives later than you’d hoped. If your parcel goes missing altogether, check whether you’re covered by the marketplace’s buyer protection scheme and report the problem before the deadline.
For more information, read Resolver’s guide to package delivery rights.
What if the seller or platform refuses your refund?
If your refund request is rejected, ask for an explanation and check the platform’s buyer protection rules. Keep copies of your evidence and challenge the decision if you believe it’s wrong.
You may also have another way to recover your money, depending on your payment method:
Chargeback: If you paid by debit or credit card, ask your card provider whether you can dispute the transaction. This may help if your item never arrived or wasn’t as described.
Section 75: If you paid directly by credit card and the cash price of an individual item was more than £100 and no more than £30,000, you may have protection under Section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act 1974. However, marketplace payment arrangements can affect eligibility.
Bank transfer: If you’ve been tricked into transferring money to a scammer, contact your bank immediately. You may qualify for reimbursement under the rules covering authorised push payment fraud, depending on the circumstances.
None of these routes guarantees a refund, but they’re worth exploring if you’ve exhausted the platform’s complaints process.
How can you shop more safely on second hand marketplaces this Christmas?
Buying second hand can help you keep Christmas costs down, but a few simple checks could save you from an expensive disappointment.
- Check seller reviews. Look for consistent feedback and be wary of newly created accounts offering unusually cheap items.
- Read the listing carefully. Check the condition, measurements, photographs and any disclosed faults.
- Keep payments on the platform. Paying outside a protected checkout system can leave you without buyer protection.
- Be wary of bank transfers. Particularly when buying from strangers or paying before collection.
- Check gifts as soon as they arrive. Don’t wait until Christmas Day and risk missing a refund deadline.
- Allow extra time for delivery. Christmas postal delays could leave you without your present or enough time to find an alternative.
- Keep your evidence. Save listings, payment confirmations and messages in case you need to dispute the sale.
And remember, a bargain isn’t really a bargain if you end up paying for something you can’t use or get your money back for.
How Resolver can help
If you’re struggling to get a refund or resolve a dispute over a second-hand purchase, Resolver can help you understand your consumer rights and explore your options.
Frequently asked questions
Can you return a second hand Christmas present after Christmas?
If you’ve bought from a private seller, you generally can’t return an item simply because it’s unwanted. When buying from a business online, you usually have 14 days from delivery to cancel an eligible purchase, although some retailers offer extended Christmas returns.
Do you have the same rights buying second-hand as buying new?
When you buy from a business, you generally have the same basic consumer rights whether the goods are new or second-hand, although their age, price and condition affect what you can reasonably expect. Buying from a private seller gives you fewer statutory protections.
Can a private seller refuse a refund?
Yes, if the item matches its description and you’ve simply changed your mind. However, if the seller misrepresented the item, you may have grounds to challenge the sale.
Can you get your money back if you’ve been scammed on Facebook Marketplace?
Possibly. If you paid through an eligible protected checkout system, you may be able to make a claim. Otherwise, contact your bank or payment provider immediately and report the seller to Facebook. Your options depend on how you paid and what happened.
Related articles
- Common Vinted complaints and how to handle them
- Vinted users speak out: Five stories of lost money and broken trust
- Vinted scams: How star-seller Tori was betrayed by the platform
- Your retail and online shopping rights explained
If you have any thoughts on this topic, or any other consumer issues you would like us to cover, feel free to get in touch with us at support@resolver.co.uk
