The reality behind buying a car online: What happens when one of the biggest purchases you’ll ever make becomes an online transaction?

For years, buying a car was a ritual, you’d spend weekends walking around forecourts, peering under bonnets, taking test drives and comparing dealerships before making one of the biggest purchases of your life.

Now, you can do all of that from your sofa, browse hundreds of vehicles, arrange the finance online, upload your documents and in just a few clicks, sit back and wait for delivery.

The rise of digital car buying has transformed the way you purchase a vehicle. Online first brands such as Cazoo and Cinch, alongside established retailers including Motorpoint and Arnold Clark, have invested heavily in making car buying faster, simpler and more convenient, and for many consumers, that’s exactly what they’ve done.

But complaints submitted through Resolver suggest an interesting question sits at the heart of the digital car boom:

What happens when one of the biggest purchases you’ll ever make becomes an online transaction?

While buying a car online may feel similar to ordering almost anything else on the internet, the reality is very different. A car isn’t a pair of trainers you can return if it doesn’t fit. It’s not a faulty kettle you can pop back in the post. It’s an essential part of your daily life, quite a major financial commitment and, for many households, one of the most expensive purchases they’ll ever make. So when something goes wrong, the consequences can be far more significant than a delayed parcel.

The “Amazonification” of car buying

Buying trust, not just a vehicle

One of the biggest differences between buying online and buying from a traditional dealership is that you’re often making a decision without ever seeing the vehicle in person, you can’t inspect every panel, check the interior or take it for a test drive before committing. Instead, you’re relying on photographs, inspection reports, descriptions and reviews; essentially you’re buying on trust.

And most of the time, that trust is well placed.

But Resolver complaint data reveals what can happen when expectations and reality don’t quite align. Across complaints involving Cazoo, Cinch, Motorpoint and Arnold Clark, consumers described issues ranging from cosmetic damage and missing features to mechanical faults that emerged shortly after purchase.

One customer told Resolver:

“The door handle came off in my hand.”

Other complaints referenced warning lights, battery issues and faults emerging shortly after delivery.

Of course, none of this is unique to digital retailers. Used cars are complex products and faults can arise regardless of where they’re purchased. But when you’ve bought a vehicle online, those issues can feel more significant because so much of the transaction relies on trust.

The further away you are from the vehicle when you make your decision, the more important that trust becomes.

That means the listing matters. Before you commit, it’s sensible to save:

• Screenshots of the vehicle description
• Photographs from the listing
• Mileage and MOT details
• Advertised features and extras
• Service history claims
• Any promises about repairs, delivery or preparation work

If you’re told a repair will be completed before delivery, keep a written record of that too. If a dispute develops later, those records can help show what you were told before you agreed to buy.

Cars don’t behave like consumer products

One reason online works so well is that most products are relatively easy to replace, repair or return, but cars are different. They’re expensive, complex and deeply embedded in your daily life. If your headphones stop working, it’s frustrating. If your car stops working, you may suddenly be unable to get to work the next morning.

One consumer who submitted a complaint through Resolver described a breakdown shortly after purchase:

“The car cut out and the battery was dead. I was stranded at the side of the road.”

Another described the stress of being left without both their money and their vehicle while trying to resolve an issue:

“I was crying and anxious as we had paid almost £9,000 in cash and part exchange and didn’t have the car for weeks.”

Reading through Resolver complaints, what’s striking isn’t simply the faults themselves, but the ripple effect that follows. Vehicle issues can quickly become transport problems, work problems, financial problems and family problems all at once. That’s very different from dealing with a faulty appliance or a damaged parcel.

It also means the inspection shouldn’t end when the car arrives.

Take your time checking the vehicle as soon as you receive it. In particular, look for:

• Damage that wasn’t disclosed in the listing
• Missing features or accessories that were advertised
• Warning lights on the dashboard
• Unusual sounds during start-up or driving
• Signs of wear to tyres, wheels or interior trim
• Any faults with controls, electronics or infotainment systems

If something doesn’t seem right, report it as soon as possible and keep evidence. Photographs, videos, emails, repair reports and diagnostic checks can all help if you need to show when a problem appeared and how you tried to resolve it.

When the digital journey meets the real world

The complaints submitted through Resolver aren’t unique to any one retailer. Consumers raised concerns involving Cazoo, Cinch, Motorpoint and Arnold Clark, but the underlying themes were often similar.

The purchasing experience has been streamlined and digitised, but the ownership experience hasn’t. Cars still need servicing, they still break down. They still require repairs, inspections and maintenance. When problems occur, consumers can find themselves dealing with garages, warranty providers, customer support teams and finance arrangements.

That complexity exists whether you buy online or from a traditional dealership. The difference is that digital retailers have raised expectations about how smooth the overall experience should feel and that makes communication crucial.

Many complaints submitted through Resolver describe customers chasing updates, repeating information to different teams or struggling to understand who was responsible for putting things right. If that happens to you, it helps to keep the conversation in writing wherever possible. If you speak on the phone, make a note of the date, time, who you spoke to and what was agreed. If you’re promised a repair, refund, callback or replacement vehicle, ask for confirmation by email. The clearer your timeline, the easier it becomes to escalate the issue if the retailer doesn’t resolve it.

The refund problem

Online car buying often comes with reassuring promises: return periods, money-back guarantees, warranties and customer support. Those protections matter, but Resolver complaint data suggests frustration can grow when consumers feel the speed of the sale isn’t matched by the speed of the resolution. Several complaints referenced delays involving deposits, refunds or financial settlements.

One consumer summarised their frustration bluntly:

“They were quick enough to take my money. I would expect the same quickness for my refunds.”

Again, the issue isn’t simply the delay itself. It’s the contrast between the speed and simplicity of buying the vehicle and the slower reality of resolving a problem afterwards.

Before buying, it’s worth checking exactly what return rights apply, how long refunds can take, what warranty cover is included and who is responsible for repairs if a fault appears shortly after delivery. Cars may now be sold through slick online journeys, but resolving a dispute can still be considerably more complicated than returning a typical online purchase.

What to do if things go wrong

The complaints submitted through Resolver don’t mean you should avoid buying a car online. For many consumers, it can be a convenient way to compare vehicles, access a wider range of stock and avoid the pressure sometimes associated with traditional dealerships. But they do show why preparation matters.

If something does go wrong, taking a structured approach can make it easier to resolve the issue. Start by:

• Contacting the retailer as soon as possible
• Explaining clearly what the issue is, when it appeared and what outcome you’re seeking
• Keeping all communication factual and professional
• Gathering evidence such as photographs, videos, inspection reports, invoices and diagnostic reports

If the retailer doesn’t resolve the issue, take the next steps:

• Follow the company’s formal complaints process
• Keep records of all correspondence and responses
• Make a note of any deadlines, promises or actions agreed
• Check your rights if the vehicle isn’t as described, isn’t of satisfactory quality or develops faults shortly after purchase

The exact protections available will depend on the circumstances, but it’s worth understanding your rights before accepting a repair, refund or rejection offer.

If you’re struggling to resolve the problem directly, Resolver can help you raise and manage your complaint, keep track of correspondence and escalate your case where appropriate.

What complaints reveal about the future of car buying

Resolver complaints don’t suggest that buying a car online is a bad idea, in fact far from it. For many consumers, online retailers have made car buying more convenient, transparent and accessible than ever before.

But they do show that technology can simplify the process of buying a car, but it can’t simplify the reality of owning one. A car remains one of the most expensive, important and emotionally significant purchases you’ll ever make and that’s why these complaints are so revealing.

They’re not simply stories about delayed deliveries, vehicle faults or refund disputes, but reminders that while buying a car may be getting easier, owning one is still something far more complicated. The digital car boom has transformed the way you buy a vehicle. The challenge for the industry now is ensuring that everything that happens after you click “Buy Now” lives up to the same promise.

If you have any thoughts on this topic, or any other consumer issues you would like us to cover, feel free to get in touch with us at support@resolver.co.uk 

Sign up for our Newsletter!